We had this thread on X-Evolution... irony of it was that I was the one who started it... and it looks like I'll be the one starting this one as well. So welcome to the Second Coming of RaS.

Here's how we do this. You post ratings of 1-10 of the person above you's sig (graphix, text or otherwise). Then, you review (a comment, maybe some CONSTRUCTIVE criticism) the sig.

The next person who posts repeats the process for your signature... and so-on-and-so-forth.

Let's start with mine. I've got the Gallantmon theme going, plus my lil' DA and Myspace link-tags. I dun have anyone to review (since I'm the first in the thread), so...

OKAY. Now that I have a new signature, I can bring this thread back. Woo!

R/C: I love how sharp the image is and I like the line/dot thing going on in the background. I also like how the character is seeming to be popping out however I'm not all that fond of how much... it increases the height majorly and I'm not a huge fan of anything over 150px vertically... preference. Also, Death Note font, amirite? I would have gone with a gray outline rather than straight white. Hurr. Wow. It's been a while since I've rated a sig. 7/10

Beo, I like you sig. Your contrast in colors is pretty beautiful, honestly.

I've never done a sig with a real life person, but you did it rather well I see.

I've no clue who that is, but it's cool.

8/10

Holy.
Background is nice, but the render is ... strange?
But since it's got Renamon I'm a little biased.
7.5/10

Mael your sig is just too cute

Though i don't know what in the world is next to the kid and looking so evil..but it is ADORABLE!

I love how the colors seem to work with the picture, but your eyes are more focus on the picture its self then anything else

8/10~

OMG PEOPLE REPLIED.

*composes self*

Beo: Thank you. I'm not that big a fan of the height of my sig either (this is the second time I've done one like that), but... the render didn't fit all that well with the background (I had to continuously shrink it to get what I wanted into the sig itself), so I decided to do it that way so I didn't have to worry about the image becoming obscure.

Your sig is awesome, as always. It's good to see you getting back in the swing of things. The color scheme and background are imazing, but what really won me over was the render. I cannot do good renders. At all. 10/10

Air: Finally found one, huh? lol

Well. The render looks a bit off with the glow and everything. But other than that... everything looks great. 9/10

Mael: I've been wanting to ask this since I saw you using that sig--what is that character from??? lol

7/10. It's kinda plain looking.

Lin: 10/10. AMAZING COLORING JOB.

I SHALL BUMP THIS TOPIC!

..sorta..

R/C: I like the sig, and the fact that:
1- your lights and darks go really well with another
2- the text is readable
3- It kinda looks like the guy just killed someone in front of a camera and there is blood everywhere o_O

My rate: 8.5/10

WELLLLL that's certainly the question now, isn't it?

Linyah: I'll be honest. The only reason I'm giving your sig a fair rating is because of the coloring job. Absolutely brilliant and kudos there. But the rest of it... if only you'd add in a little more graphical detail. Something more than a gradient in the background. Hurrr. Also. Font choice. *scratches head* Not too sure on that one either. Also. Artifacts. Hurr. 5/10

@R/C: Ha, thanks! I'm getting better with renders all the time. My font choices have kinda swung around though... gotta get that back into shape. >.>

Awesome colouring and render ^-^
Nothing much more to say, except that Beo, you've always done some of my favourite sigs ^^
9/10
Minus one because it's kinda bright in a dark room XD;

I love how your sig is so simplistic, yet it somehow just works. That's some real cool work. I also love how the black bars on top and bottom frame the image so well, and add to the feel to the image immensely - even if it's such a simple addition to the image. If anything could be better... The colouring of the blue background? If you had edited it out and re-painted it in using a gradient or something, it would have massively improved the image... Then again, you might have lost the raw simplicity of the image if you were to make even a simple alteration like that... So... Yeah...

Anyways - I rate it 8.5/10


Side-note: I couldn't pass through this thread without saying - I LOVE your sig, Beo! David Tennant has never looked so good! Nice work. 10/10 from me, guaranteed.



EDIT: Stupid IPB being evil and annoying - won't let me make the 8.5 a larger size and bold at the sme time.
EDIT2: OK - fixed... hopefully...
EDIT3: *sigh* now the first 10 in the 10/10 for Beo is not working right.
EDIT4: OK... fixed... again... hopefully...
EDIT5: Gah! It failed! And it screwed the coding of the post up! Fixing...
EDIT6: YAY! Fixed! AGAIN! ...Hopefully...
Stupid throw-a-six-to-start system... *goes off ranting*

Firefly. I like your Sig, but it seems really small. Maybe it's becasue it's in the middle... You could try making it longer. Also, i like how it reminds me of a Ticket or something from Digimon (which is what I'm guessing you was going for). All in all I'd give it a 8/10.

The background is nice and so is your name at the bottom. However, the symbol is of low quality. Plus, I feel there's too much empty space.

7/10

Your sig is of a good theme, and the colours are cool. However, the text doesn't really fit, and the font style doesn't fit. Also, the sig seems a little too tall. And the transparency doesn't seem to be working properly, leaving a white bar at the top of the sig. But these are small niggly problems, and otherwise your sig looks really good.

...I give it a...
6/10
- Good - but some things could be better.

I'm liking the shape and funky fonts. I also like how there's that big ol' blue splat in the middle and a bunch of rings around it.
What I'm not into is the font of the subtext - I dunno. I think I'd prefer something with less curves. It doesn't seem to match the thing you've got going.

Anyways:

8/10

Hmm. For Chloe's Signature.. I like the text below it, but I feel the signature has too many marks on the sky/stone on the upper-half which really distract one's attention from the barren landscape. Along with the words covering it up. In my opinion? Words should be moved to the upper half.

5/10

Sorry.

I love your sig and adore how the animation isn't big and flashy (OmG I just noticed the knight's eyes!).

The font fits very well and the moon on it is awesome. Generally, a very nice sig.

9/10

Just because the quality of the knight isn't top notch.

6/10.

There's probably a joke in the sig that I'm not getting. It really needs some refining, but, it has good base potential. Needs a more defined boarder, and perhaps something besides a very copy-and-pasted looking image. The text should perhaps be filled in or, not faded at the edges.

0/10

You don't have a sig on you right now. I think your best bet is getting one. -_-

-casts revive-

Red: 7/10
Reason: It isn't bad, i do like how you did the animation. [personally i couldn't do that at all XD] Just the lighting..i could of seen it a different color then purple o_o then again that is just me XD

I like the actual image, but the text is meh. Mainly because I dislike mispellings, and because I just don't like it.
9/10 on the image
4/10 on the words

6/10 overall.

what misspellings? o_o the text is spelled like that in an avatar i have somewhere...

I think he means just 'luff' in general being a misspelling of Love. But as to your current sig? 7/10. I like the simplicity of it, but the blurry background bothers my eyes some, hate to say.

You know how hard it is for me to make a sig!?

IT IS HARD! [lawl not really XD]

btw..wtf is that thing in your sig? O_o it looks creepy..

7.5/10 XD

I rate... 6/10.

you signature is... different. I like it. 9/10.

Just for further information on it, who is the character depicted in your signature, by the way?

Yah know it's good, it's was ok but I felt this sig wasn't connecting with you, pick another sig next week and I hope to see you in the top 10 this week. [/randyjackson]

7/10

Hmm... it's a bit simple, but it works. 8/10--the actual Nazca would have been better than the chibi.

alright. back. With newer sig.

I actually got three really good Nazca images that I want to use but I never decided which one I want to sue. :|

Your new sig looks pretty cool. I like the burshes. Mind drop the link for em?

9/7

*nervous laugh*

I... don't remember where I got them. Hold up. Let me see if i can find it.

Here. I uploaded it to mediafire.

http://www.mediafire.com/?wuwm2ylmmwn

I like your sig this time around
Black War Greymon X works, and yes it does ^^
The left side isn't too bare, and blue always works for me.
The digital-like-sorta background works too, and no text! That's refreshing.

8.5/10

T_T I still need to read the manga yours is from.

Go watch the anime. There's an anime for it.

...uh... what was the name again...?

And... let's try to steer things back on topic.

Hmm... coulda sworn I'd already rated yours.

Anyways. 8/10. Simple... but I mean... it could use some flashy effects or something. I dunno. >.> I like the header and footer border you got, though.

New (ugly) set for the year!

Nice 8/10

I like the wordless touch.

I never did get this thign rated

Hmmm...
My standard rating of 6/10 applies xD
Sorry, just don't want to be overly critical and it's not really my art style.

R/C: The character in my sig is from Aion Online
You always have an awesome avatar... where do you get them?

R/C's avatar is of Kamen Rider Decade.
I saw something similar on tvnihon's forums ... but I think he probably did it himself.

PHOENIX DOWN!

"Rate-a-Sig Advent" was Revived!

*cough*

Anyways. A new sig to match my new obsession--Needless! And... one of the main chars, Adam Blade.

Also added some new "currently following" and updated my projects.

Hehe.
I kinda like your set R/C.
Even though I don't know who's inside .. yeah ... but it feels rather antagonistic.
Iunno.

8.5/10

The avatar kinda ... well ... ain't my taste.

Mine either... it's one of the only cool pics of Adam Blade I could find. >.>; I wanted to use one from when he first meets Mio in the show... but I didn't know if I should or not.

Next up is a Graham Acre sig and avy. o.O I'm working on pics now.

o~O
Like I said in AIM, cool sig~

New set. KR W/Double!

yea... not crazy about the skull stock image tho. :/

Maelstrom: niiice. I dig the slash marks in the background. FangJoker... definitely one of my fave W combinations.

10/10